kite/.planning/phases/12-cloud-resource-foundation/12-VALIDATION.md

phase, slug, status, nyquist_compliant, wave_0_complete, created, last_audited

phase	slug	status	nyquist_compliant	wave_0_complete	created	last_audited
12	cloud-resource-foundation	complete	true	true	2026-06-18	2026-06-22

Phase 12 — Validation Strategy

Post-execution validation contract and Nyquist audit evidence for the cloud resource foundation.

---

Test Infrastructure

Property	Value
Framework	pytest 9.x, Vitest 4.x, Vue Test Utils 2.x
Config file	backend/pytest.ini, frontend/vitest.config.js
Quick backend command	docker compose run --rm backend pytest -q tests/test_cloud.py tests/test_cloud_backends.py tests/test_cloud_capabilities.py tests/test_cloud_items.py tests/test_cloud_security.py tests/test_compose_migrations.py tests/test_migration_0006.py
Quick frontend command	cd frontend && npm test -- --run src/components/storage/__tests__/StorageBrowser.capabilities.test.js src/components/ui/__tests__/BreadcrumbBar.test.js src/views/__tests__/CloudFolderView.test.js src/views/__tests__/CloudStorageView.test.js src/stores/__tests__/cloudConnections.test.js src/components/settings/__tests__/SettingsCloudTab.test.js src/components/cloud/__tests__/CloudCredentialModal.test.js src/components/cloud/__tests__/CloudProviderTreeItem.test.js src/components/cloud/__tests__/CloudFolderTreeItem.test.js src/components/layout/__tests__/AppSidebar.test.js
Full suite command	cd backend && pytest -v; cd frontend && npm test; cd frontend && npm run build
Fresh focused runtime	Backend cloud/migration slice 159 passed, 12 prerequisite skips in 3.48 s plus 7 Compose contract tests in 0.23 s; frontend focused slice 76 passed in 1.12 s (2026-06-22)

---

Sampling Rate

• After every task commit: Run the focused test file(s) named by that task.
• After every plan wave: Run backend and frontend suites for all touched layers.
• Before /gsd:verify-work: Run the full backend suite, full frontend suite, production build, and required PostgreSQL integration tests.
• Max observed focused feedback latency: 4.14 seconds, excluding container startup.

---

Per-Task Verification Map

Task ID	Plan	Wave	Requirement	Threat Ref	Secure Behavior	Test Type	Automated Evidence	File Exists	Status
12-01-01	01	1	CONN-04, CLOUD-08	T-12-06	Capability discovery is normalized and never mutates provider content	unit	tests/test_cloud_capabilities.py	✅	✅ green
12-01-02	01	1	CACHE-02, SYNC-01	T-12-01, T-12-02	Metadata/search state is owner and connection scoped without byte storage	unit + DB	tests/test_cloud_items.py schema, isolation, quota cases	✅	✅ green
12-01-03	01	1	CACHE-02, SYNC-01	T-12-07	Reconciliation is stable and incomplete listings cannot delete unseen items	service	tests/test_cloud_items.py reconciliation cases	✅	✅ green
12-02-01	02	2	CONN-04, SYNC-01	T-12-04, T-12-06	All providers normalize complete metadata/capability listings through read-only calls	adapter contract	tests/test_cloud_backends.py	✅	✅ green
12-02-02	02	2	CLOUD-01, CLOUD-08	T-12-01, T-12-03	Connection-ID browse rejects foreign/admin access and excludes credentials	API integration	tests/test_cloud.py, tests/test_cloud_security.py	✅	✅ green
12-02-03	02	2	CACHE-01, SYNC-01	T-12-07, T-12-09	Refresh retries safely, retains metadata on failure, and downloads no bytes	task/service	tests/test_cloud_items.py refresh/no-byte cases	✅	✅ green
12-03-01	03	3	CONN-04, CLOUD-01	T-12-01, T-12-11	Routes/stores use connection UUID and session storage contains folder references only	store/view	cloudConnections, CloudStorageView, CloudFolderView, SettingsCloudTab tests	✅	✅ green
12-03-02	03	3	CONN-04, CLOUD-08	T-12-10	Disabled controls are focusable/explanatory and suppress pointer/keyboard/touch actions	component	StorageBrowser.capabilities.test.js	✅	✅ green
12-03-03	03	3	CLOUD-01, SYNC-01	T-12-12	Breadcrumb freshness states are accessible and cached rows stay usable	component	BreadcrumbBar.test.js, CloudFolderView.test.js	✅	✅ green
12-04-01	04	4	All Phase 12	T-12-01..10	Dedicated owner/admin/credential/SSRF/no-byte negatives close cross-layer threats	integration/regression	tests/test_cloud_security.py plus focused suites	✅	✅ green
12-04-02	04	4	CONN-04, CLOUD-08	T-12-SC	Static/dependency security gates have no unresolved Phase 12 blocker	security gate	SECURITY.md Phase 12 evidence	✅	✅ green
12-04-03	04	4	All Phase 12	—	Documentation/version claims match tracked shipped behavior	source + suites	12-VERIFICATION.md, summaries, version source assertions	✅	✅ green
12-05-01	05	5	CONN-04, CLOUD-01	T-12-05-01..04	Exactly one hardened migrate service gates backend/worker/beat startup	compose contract	tests/test_compose_migrations.py; docker compose config --quiet	✅	✅ green
12-05-02	05	5	CONN-04, CLOUD-01	T-12-05-01, T-12-05-02	A disposable PostgreSQL database upgrades 0005→0006 and preserves DDL separation	PostgreSQL integration	tests/test_migration_0006.py (12 tests; explicit prerequisite skip without disposable DSN)	✅	✅ green
12-05-03	05	5	CONN-04, CLOUD-01	T-12-05-03, T-12-05-04	Cloud APIs run against migrated schema without credential disclosure	API regression + config	tests/test_cloud.py, tests/test_cloud_security.py, Compose config validation	✅	✅ green
12-06-01	06	6	CONN-04, CLOUD-01	T-12-06-01..05	Same-provider accounts create independently; edits target one owned UUID; errors stay actionable and credential-free	API + component	tests/test_cloud.py, tests/test_cloud_security.py, SettingsCloudTab.test.js, CloudCredentialModal.test.js	✅	✅ green
12-06-02	06	6	CLOUD-01, CLOUD-08	T-12-06-06	Sidebar browse/routes use connection UUIDs; breadcrumbs and deepest-node active state survive refresh failure	component/view	CloudProviderTreeItem.test.js, CloudFolderTreeItem.test.js, AppSidebar.test.js, CloudFolderView.test.js, CloudStorageView.test.js	✅	✅ green
12-06-03	06	6	CONN-04, CLOUD-01, CLOUD-08	T-12-06-SC	UAT regressions, version alignment, build, and security gates remain release-ready	cross-layer suite	Phase summaries/security evidence plus focused and full-suite commands	✅	✅ green

Status: ✅ green · ❌ red · ⚠️ partial/manual

---

Requirement Coverage

Requirement	Status	Automated evidence
CONN-04	COVERED	Capability contract tests, independent same-provider lifecycle and owner-targeted edit tests, connection store/settings tests, StorageBrowser action-state tests
CLOUD-01	COVERED	Migration-gated startup tests, connection-ID API tests, UUID-only sidebar navigation, and shared CloudStorageView/CloudFolderView/StorageBrowser tests
CLOUD-08	COVERED	Unsupported/temporarily-unavailable state, message, pointer, Enter, Space, and touch suppression tests
CACHE-01	COVERED	No-MinIO, no-byte-download, no-quota-mutation browse/refresh tests
CACHE-02	COVERED	Cloud metadata/extracted text/topic/semantic fields and cross-connection isolation tests
SYNC-01	COVERED	Provider normalization plus durable item/reconciliation/freshness tests

---

Wave 0 Requirements

• backend/tests/test_cloud_capabilities.py — capability normalization, reason states, safe discovery, item overrides.
• backend/tests/test_cloud_items.py — owner-scoped persistence, stable identity, reconciliation, metadata-only invariants.
• Database constraint/isolation coverage for UUID ownership, unique connection/item identity, and cascade behavior.
• CloudFolderView.test.js and CloudStorageView.test.js — thin shared-browser view integration.
• Provider response fixtures for Google Drive, OneDrive, Nextcloud, and generic WebDAV normalization.
• test_compose_migrations.py and test_migration_0006.py — startup gate and disposable PostgreSQL 0005→0006 regression.
• CloudCredentialModal.test.js — new-vs-edit endpoint selection, connection-ID targeting, omitted-password preservation, and actionable errors.
• Connection tree/sidebar tests — UUID-only routes, nested folder selection, and exact overview active state.
• Fresh focused runtime recorded for backend, frontend, and Compose contract slices.

---

Manual-Only Verifications

Behavior	Requirement	Why Manual	Test Instructions
Tooltip placement and clarity across desktop/mobile viewports	CLOUD-08	Visual placement and viewport clipping require a rendered browser	Hover and keyboard-focus a gray/amber cloud action on desktop, then tap it on mobile; verify readable explanation, no overlap, and no underlying action
Cached-first transition and freshness presentation	CLOUD-01, SYNC-01	Perceived flicker, layout stability, and continued row usability are visual qualities	Seed durable metadata, delay/fail provider refresh, navigate the folder, and verify rows remain interactive while refreshing/warning indicators and last-update copy render correctly

These checks supplement automated coverage; no Phase 12 requirement depends solely on manual verification.

---

Validation Audit 2026-06-22

Metric	Count
Phase requirements audited	6
Automated requirements covered	6
Executed plans audited	6
Gaps found	1
Tests generated	1 file / 3 tests
Gaps escalated to manual-only	0
Supplementary manual visual checks retained	2

Gap Closed

• Plan 12-06 named frontend/src/components/cloud/__tests__/CloudCredentialModal.test.js as required automated evidence, but the file was absent; only a mobile-layout test existed.
• Generated the missing functional suite with three regressions: fresh Nextcloud creation builds the WebDAV URL and calls create, editing targets the selected connection UUID while omitting a blank password, and API validation detail remains visible without closing the modal.

Fresh Execution Evidence

• Backend cloud/migration focused slice: 159 passed, 12 skipped, 1 non-failing SlowAPI deprecation warning, 3.48 s. The 12 migration integration cases correctly require an explicitly disposable PostgreSQL DSN and did not touch the development database.
• Compose migration contract: 7 passed in 0.23 s with the repository Compose file mounted read-only into the backend test container.
• Frontend focused suite after gap closure: 76 passed across 10 files, 1.12 s.
• Compose environment contract: docker compose config --quiet passed with required variables resolved.
• Execution closeout evidence: backend 509 passed with one documented environment-only libmagic failure; frontend 323 passed; production build succeeded.
• Later Plan 12-06 closeout evidence: backend 516 passed (7 xfailed, 17 skipped), frontend 334 passed across 42 files, and production build succeeded.
• Phase verification: .planning/phases/12-cloud-resource-foundation/12-VERIFICATION.md status passed; versions align at 0.2.2.

---

Validation Sign-Off

• Every Phase 12 requirement has targeted automated verification.
• Every executed task has automated or explicit source/security evidence.
• Sampling continuity contains no three-task gap.
• Wave 0 files and fixtures exist.
• Commands use one-shot test modes, not watch mode.
• Focused feedback latency is below 60 seconds.
• nyquist_compliant: true is set in frontmatter.

Approval: approved 2026-06-22