Files
kite/.planning/phases/14-selective-analysis-and-byte-cache/14-VALIDATION.md
T
curo1305andClaude Sonnet 4.6 90e1b525f1 docs(14-09): Phase 14 closeout — docs, version bump v0.3.0→v0.4.0, security evidence
- CLAUDE.md/AGENTS.md: update current-state line to v0.4.0 Phase 14 complete;
  add Phase 14 shared module map entries (cloud_cache, cloud_analysis,
  cloud_analysis_processing, cloud_analysis_tasks, analysis router, cache API);
  add Phase 14 non-negotiable rules (hydrate_and_cache_bytes single entry point,
  IDs-only broker payload, object_key/credentials_enc excluded at schema level)
- README.md: bump to v0.4.0; add Selective cloud analysis and Cloud byte cache
  features; add Analysis API table (Phase 14 endpoints)
- SECURITY.md: add Phase 14 threat register (T-14-01..T-14-15) with evidence,
  security gate results, and accepted risks
- backend/main.py: bump FastAPI version to 0.4.0
- frontend/package.json: bump version to 0.4.0
- ROADMAP.md: mark Phase 14 complete (9/9 plans), plan 14-09 checked off
- 14-VALIDATION.md: gate evidence, requirement coverage, acceptance criteria check
- 14-SECURITY.md: security evidence summary and gate checklist

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-23 20:05:49 +02:00

4.0 KiB

Phase 14 — Validation Record

Phase: 14 — Selective Analysis and Byte Cache Validated: 2026-06-23 Validator: gsd-execute-phase (claude-sonnet-4-6) Status: COMPLETE — all gates passed

Summary

Phase 14 ships selective cloud analysis (ANALYZE-01 through ANALYZE-07) and a durable byte cache (CACHE-03, CACHE-04, CACHE-05). All 9 plans were executed, all verification gates pass, and the version was bumped to v0.4.0 (minor increment per CLAUDE.md protocol for full phase completion).

Gate Results

Gate Check Result Evidence
Backend test suite pytest -q PASS 856 passed, 18 skipped, 7 xfailed; 1 pre-existing failure (test_extract_docx — docx env)
Frontend test suite npm run test PASS 471 passed (50 test files)
Bandit HIGH severity bandit -r backend/ --exclude backend/tests --severity-level high PASS 0 HIGH, 0 MEDIUM; 23 Low (all pre-existing)
npm audit npm audit --audit-level=high PASS 0 vulnerabilities
docker compose config docker compose config --quiet PASS No output — all env vars resolve
Secret scan gitleaks detect --redact PASS 3 pre-existing findings (all before Phase 14)
pip-audit Tooling gap (Python 3.9 local env) ACCEPTED No new Python packages in Phase 14; Phase 8 audit clean

Requirement Coverage

Requirement What Was Built Plans
ANALYZE-01 Single-file estimate from metadata; Celery processing 14-01, 14-04, 14-05
ANALYZE-02 Multi-selection estimate with unsupported count 14-01, 14-04
ANALYZE-03 Folder-tree and whole-connection estimate (recursive) 14-01, 14-04
ANALYZE-04 Job status with simple/detailed aggregate and per-stage counts 14-04, 14-07
ANALYZE-05 Per-item cancel, skip, retry; Cancel all batch 14-04, 14-07
ANALYZE-06 Already-current detection via version_key; changed etag triggers requeue 14-02, 14-04
ANALYZE-07 Provider mutation methods never called during analysis 14-03, 14-05
CACHE-03 Cache entry created during analysis; browse never creates cache entries 14-02, 14-03
CACHE-04 Configurable cache limit; LRU eviction skips pinned entries 14-02, 14-03, 14-08
CACHE-05 Cache quota increment/decrement; per-user isolation 14-02, 14-03

Phase Acceptance Criteria Check

  1. Users can analyze one file, multi-selection, folder tree, or whole connection after reviewing recursive estimates. Status: PASS — estimate API + frontend modal implemented (14-04, 14-07).

  2. UI exposes aggregate and per-item states with retry and cancellation. Status: PASS — analysis queue with expand/collapse, per-item cancel/retry/skip, Cancel all batch (14-07).

  3. Analysis jobs are idempotent by cloud item and provider version/etag; never mutate the provider. Status: PASS — already-current detection, stale guard, mutation_call_count==0 test (14-04, 14-05).

  4. Cloud bytes cached only for active work and evicted by configurable limits without interrupting pinned active jobs. Status: PASS — LRU eviction skips pin_count>0, cache limit configurable, Settings UI (14-03, 14-08).

  5. Cache ownership, cache-key versioning, cancellation, duplicate-job, failure-retry, and eviction have dedicated tests. Status: PASS — test_cloud_cache.py (30 tests), test_cloud_analysis_contract.py (47 tests), test_cloud_analysis_api.py (14 tests), test_cloud_security.py (analysis/cache subset).

Pre-Existing Issues (Not Phase 14 Scope)

  • test_extract_docxModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'docx' — python-docx/libmagic not installed in local test environment. Pre-existing; not a Phase 14 regression.
  • pip-audit local tooling gap — Python 3.9 local environment cannot install pip-audit for Python 3.12 requirements. Accepted risk (same gap as Phases 12 and 13). No new Python packages were added in Phase 14.
  • gitleaks 3 pre-existing findings — all in test files committed before Phase 14 (May 2026).